I'm curious as to why you don't consider this quote to be credible:
“Today it is estimated by Jacob's grandson, John Schiff, that the old man sank about $20,000,000 for the final triumph of Bolshevism in Russia."
Not sure if you've read it, but Ron Unz mentions this in his article on the Bolshevik revolution and considers it to be very credible. He's defended it multiple times in comments too. He claims that the New York Journal American was one of the leading papers in New York at the time and the quote would have certainly been disputed by John Schiff if it wasn't authentic.
You might find Unz's article interesting also because it provides more sources on the funding of the Bolsheviks by Jewish bankers.
Didn't know Unz wrote on this, I'll give it a read. I don't consider it credible by itself because it's a second-hand account of a statement by Schiff's grandson, apparently published in a tabloid with no further source and with nothing else to corroborate it. It would be such a noteworthy transfer we could surely expect someone would have found something else corroborating it by now.
I believe what Unz has said in the past is that the sum likely represents the total spent by Schiff on revolutionary forces over the years. It's very well documented that Schiff heavily funded the 1905 revolution so the sum likely includes that. It's unlikely that all of this money went specifically to the Bolsheviks though, as opposed to various groups, especially through Trotsky, as was claimed by US military intelligence at the time.
Times of London editor Henry Wickham Steed does claim that Schiff lobbied on behalf of the Bolsheviks at the 1919 Paris Peace Conference though. It's said that Schiff was a conservative and cut off support after the October revolution, but that seems pretty questionable. As we've seen with the neocon movement and its origins, the line between "conservative" and "communist" is frequently pretty blurred with Jews.
We need to clear out the slop and misinformation on the Jewish question so that we can make a plausible case for our beliefs and aims. We absolutely can, we just need to stick to the facts. Good work Keith.
We have lots of writers and speakers on that subject, but this documentary is not meant to give us a plausible case for our beliefs or aims, its a propaganda film meant to shake people out of zionist lies. When I watched it, I probably forgot half of what I saw, but I was compelled to study more. Everyone who is redpilled by Europa says the same thing. The movie is not a factual bible to us - its a piece to inspire and wake up through 12 grueling hours of anti-semitism.
it doesnt discredit anything keith, it just makes the documentary not as useful for a wider audience. The truth in the documentary points to one conclusion:
jews are wicked foreigners and must leave.
Some dishonesty in a documentary doesn't change this.
Well if someone is deliberately lying so much perhaps it's an indication of some agenda behind this documentary. Mobilising someone to hate a certain ethnic/religious group is not always a good thing.
With all these tedious nitpicks, I'm starting to wonder who's side Keith is on. For every error you find here, you can find a thousand pieces of utterly damning evidence supporting our claims.
Calling these "tedious nitpicks" is dishonest. Saying seven out of seven, rather than one of the people who met to promote the Federal Reserve is monumentally dishonest. So is saying all the assassins of the Romanov family were Jewish. So is saying Jacob Schiff gave Trotsky 20 million in gold.
If there are a thousand pieces of damning evidence for every error, then all the more reason to discard these errors once and for all.
Considering the collossal iceberg of information that must surely be contained in this 12 hour documentary, the truth/falsity ratio you have uncovered here is remarkably unimpressive. In any case, you have seen the collages yourself, Keith. All those ugly faces with ✡️ next to them. It is nauseatingly familiar to us. The normie knows none of it, though, nor does he want to. I commend documentaries like ETLB and TGSNT for attempting to gather all the scholarship we have produced into a single source. It's a gargantuan task, as the literature spans decades and is the product of many different minds. In fact, the sheer tonnage of evidence we have on our side actually works against us, because it is not succinctly communicable. This is a devastating handicap, considering that our own people have been inoculated against listening to us for even two seconds, let alone 12 hours. Short of putting a gun to their heads and forcing them to watch, there is no way to impart the information. Forcing them probably wouldn't work, anyway. Their anger towards us would prevent them from absorbing the data. The real problem is that the enemy got inside their heads first. Once the enemy has laid down roots in our peoples' minds, it's game over. Facts and truth don't really matter if you introduce them late in the game.
Oh I read them, but I don't have the time or the patience to sit through a 12 hour documentary to learn stuff I've already heard many times before. Hats off to anyone who does, though. In a world where attention spans are getting shorter by the day, that is no mean feat.
The whole movie is full of bullshit. I believe JQ people on X are psyop, spreading falsehoods and blocking people for pointing it out. It is very convenient for the ruling class to blame every fault of capitalism on "Bolsheviks".
it is not convenient for jews if Europeans grow to hate jews. This sort of thinking is stupid. Anti-semitism exists because of semitism. They need to leave.
No one is promoting it. I am virulently anti Semitic and get banned all the time from the major social media sites. You are being silly. Jews want controlled opposition, not real opposition
I've heard this a lot. I think it's retarded. Jews have consistently tried to squash actual anti semites while seeking to control anti semites. They want controlled opposition not real opposition.
Jews do not want European men to violently hate them. Think about what I am saying. They want controlled opposition, not actual enemies seeking their destruction.
They are afraid of reasonable criticism. People uncovering Talmud and all of their conspiring and shady things they are involved. But people wanting to kill everyone with Jewish ancestry or big nose are just helping them to stick together.
Your reasons are bad. They've been welcomed and converted before and they still stick together. They have full freedom in the West today and they still stick together even though there is no powerful White group trying to get them.
Listen dude, intelligent men have already written and spoken about jews at length for centuries. It's time to acknowledge the situation. These are enemies, and they are intent on controlling us. We should defeat them.
Anything else is weakness. They do not want us defeating them. They want us thinking jews can be integrated when they cannot. It's already been tried, a lot.
Only imagine how much time was required to do all of this research. Sure hope you were paid handsomely for it. Or, perhaps, someone else did all the grunt work for you? Either way, gotta wonder what precisely is the return on investment? Hmm
It is time consuming, I am not being paid to do it except by my subscribers here, and none of it is outsourced. It would be nice if some billionaire would pay me to autistically fact-check schizo bitchute documentaries, but unfortunately it doesn't seem to be a priority for them.
Propaganda is meant to rile and rise. Most propaganda is a mixture of truth and lies. Also, jews are enemies to Europe. If you pay attention to Keith's article, the majority of the anti jewish claims are correct. So, it doesn't matter if there's a lie here or there.
Jews need to leave the west. They need to stop pushing liberalisma and civnattery
Keith... I'm on the telegram channel for europa... they actually want to reach out to you to work with you to refine the documentary... you should get in contact with them...https://t.me/europa_the_last_battle_blu_ray
The revolution of 1917 was made by the hands of the workers of the Petrograd factories who came out and the soldiers of the reserve units who marched behind socialist slogans.
Political agitators had gone nowhere since 1905 and had been active all along.
The Petrograd Soviet of Workers‘ and Soldiers’ Deputies was established in the early days of the February Revolution and claimed supreme power not only in Petrograd, but in the whole of Russia.
The Tsar abdicated to the least of the evils - the State Duma. but they had no real power in the streets, so everything ended with the October Revolution.
I'm curious as to why you don't consider this quote to be credible:
“Today it is estimated by Jacob's grandson, John Schiff, that the old man sank about $20,000,000 for the final triumph of Bolshevism in Russia."
Not sure if you've read it, but Ron Unz mentions this in his article on the Bolshevik revolution and considers it to be very credible. He's defended it multiple times in comments too. He claims that the New York Journal American was one of the leading papers in New York at the time and the quote would have certainly been disputed by John Schiff if it wasn't authentic.
You might find Unz's article interesting also because it provides more sources on the funding of the Bolsheviks by Jewish bankers.
https://www.unz.com/runz/american-pravda-the-bolshevik-revolution-and-its-aftermath/
Didn't know Unz wrote on this, I'll give it a read. I don't consider it credible by itself because it's a second-hand account of a statement by Schiff's grandson, apparently published in a tabloid with no further source and with nothing else to corroborate it. It would be such a noteworthy transfer we could surely expect someone would have found something else corroborating it by now.
I believe what Unz has said in the past is that the sum likely represents the total spent by Schiff on revolutionary forces over the years. It's very well documented that Schiff heavily funded the 1905 revolution so the sum likely includes that. It's unlikely that all of this money went specifically to the Bolsheviks though, as opposed to various groups, especially through Trotsky, as was claimed by US military intelligence at the time.
Times of London editor Henry Wickham Steed does claim that Schiff lobbied on behalf of the Bolsheviks at the 1919 Paris Peace Conference though. It's said that Schiff was a conservative and cut off support after the October revolution, but that seems pretty questionable. As we've seen with the neocon movement and its origins, the line between "conservative" and "communist" is frequently pretty blurred with Jews.
We need to clear out the slop and misinformation on the Jewish question so that we can make a plausible case for our beliefs and aims. We absolutely can, we just need to stick to the facts. Good work Keith.
We have lots of writers and speakers on that subject, but this documentary is not meant to give us a plausible case for our beliefs or aims, its a propaganda film meant to shake people out of zionist lies. When I watched it, I probably forgot half of what I saw, but I was compelled to study more. Everyone who is redpilled by Europa says the same thing. The movie is not a factual bible to us - its a piece to inspire and wake up through 12 grueling hours of anti-semitism.
it doesnt discredit anything keith, it just makes the documentary not as useful for a wider audience. The truth in the documentary points to one conclusion:
jews are wicked foreigners and must leave.
Some dishonesty in a documentary doesn't change this.
Well if someone is deliberately lying so much perhaps it's an indication of some agenda behind this documentary. Mobilising someone to hate a certain ethnic/religious group is not always a good thing.
With all these tedious nitpicks, I'm starting to wonder who's side Keith is on. For every error you find here, you can find a thousand pieces of utterly damning evidence supporting our claims.
Calling these "tedious nitpicks" is dishonest. Saying seven out of seven, rather than one of the people who met to promote the Federal Reserve is monumentally dishonest. So is saying all the assassins of the Romanov family were Jewish. So is saying Jacob Schiff gave Trotsky 20 million in gold.
If there are a thousand pieces of damning evidence for every error, then all the more reason to discard these errors once and for all.
Considering the collossal iceberg of information that must surely be contained in this 12 hour documentary, the truth/falsity ratio you have uncovered here is remarkably unimpressive. In any case, you have seen the collages yourself, Keith. All those ugly faces with ✡️ next to them. It is nauseatingly familiar to us. The normie knows none of it, though, nor does he want to. I commend documentaries like ETLB and TGSNT for attempting to gather all the scholarship we have produced into a single source. It's a gargantuan task, as the literature spans decades and is the product of many different minds. In fact, the sheer tonnage of evidence we have on our side actually works against us, because it is not succinctly communicable. This is a devastating handicap, considering that our own people have been inoculated against listening to us for even two seconds, let alone 12 hours. Short of putting a gun to their heads and forcing them to watch, there is no way to impart the information. Forcing them probably wouldn't work, anyway. Their anger towards us would prevent them from absorbing the data. The real problem is that the enemy got inside their heads first. Once the enemy has laid down roots in our peoples' minds, it's game over. Facts and truth don't really matter if you introduce them late in the game.
It sounds like you haven't watched the doc or read my articles
Oh I read them, but I don't have the time or the patience to sit through a 12 hour documentary to learn stuff I've already heard many times before. Hats off to anyone who does, though. In a world where attention spans are getting shorter by the day, that is no mean feat.
False information should absolutely be called out. If left unchecked, it will discredit us.
The whole movie is full of bullshit. I believe JQ people on X are psyop, spreading falsehoods and blocking people for pointing it out. It is very convenient for the ruling class to blame every fault of capitalism on "Bolsheviks".
it is not convenient for jews if Europeans grow to hate jews. This sort of thinking is stupid. Anti-semitism exists because of semitism. They need to leave.
Who said it's the jews promoting the JQ in social? But someone is most certainly promoting this
No one is promoting it. I am virulently anti Semitic and get banned all the time from the major social media sites. You are being silly. Jews want controlled opposition, not real opposition
The opposite. They are afraid of assimilation much more than antisemitism.
"the anti-Semites will become our most dependable friends, the anti-Semitic countries our allies" - Herzl
Without ethno based antisemites, there would be no Jews. They disappear via intermarriage and assimilation long ago.
You provide no way out for Jews but double down on their tribalism.
Their way out is to leave. Fool.
https://www.jewishnews.co.uk/top-rabbi-jews-assimilation-europe-worse-holocaust/
We don't want them. Get that through your head.
I've heard this a lot. I think it's retarded. Jews have consistently tried to squash actual anti semites while seeking to control anti semites. They want controlled opposition not real opposition.
Jews do not want European men to violently hate them. Think about what I am saying. They want controlled opposition, not actual enemies seeking their destruction.
They are afraid of reasonable criticism. People uncovering Talmud and all of their conspiring and shady things they are involved. But people wanting to kill everyone with Jewish ancestry or big nose are just helping them to stick together.
Your reasons are bad. They've been welcomed and converted before and they still stick together. They have full freedom in the West today and they still stick together even though there is no powerful White group trying to get them.
Listen dude, intelligent men have already written and spoken about jews at length for centuries. It's time to acknowledge the situation. These are enemies, and they are intent on controlling us. We should defeat them.
Anything else is weakness. They do not want us defeating them. They want us thinking jews can be integrated when they cannot. It's already been tried, a lot.
Consider my words.
Only imagine how much time was required to do all of this research. Sure hope you were paid handsomely for it. Or, perhaps, someone else did all the grunt work for you? Either way, gotta wonder what precisely is the return on investment? Hmm
It is time consuming, I am not being paid to do it except by my subscribers here, and none of it is outsourced. It would be nice if some billionaire would pay me to autistically fact-check schizo bitchute documentaries, but unfortunately it doesn't seem to be a priority for them.
Jews are pure evil
RIP Tsar Nicholas. We will avenge your death.
Would be cool if Keith remade to the documentary with straight facts and better music
I always preferred TGSNT.
TGSNT is similar meme slop
You are meme slop, moor
I recommend reading the “Ritual Regicide” series on the World War Now substack regarding the jewish ritual murder of the Romanov families. It goes into extensive detail. Pt. 1 is available in full, for free on Unz Review here: https://www.unz.com/article/ritual-regicide-the-martyrdom-of-the-romanovs-part-i/
Propaganda is meant to rile and rise. Most propaganda is a mixture of truth and lies. Also, jews are enemies to Europe. If you pay attention to Keith's article, the majority of the anti jewish claims are correct. So, it doesn't matter if there's a lie here or there.
Jews need to leave the west. They need to stop pushing liberalisma and civnattery
I thought Sverdlov took part in the assassination and I heard other sources claiming he perpetrated this in a ritualistic manner.
Keith... I'm on the telegram channel for europa... they actually want to reach out to you to work with you to refine the documentary... you should get in contact with them...https://t.me/europa_the_last_battle_blu_ray
But Bolsheviks did not topple the tsarist government. They toppled Karensky government.
The revolution of 1917 was made by the hands of the workers of the Petrograd factories who came out and the soldiers of the reserve units who marched behind socialist slogans.
Political agitators had gone nowhere since 1905 and had been active all along.
The Petrograd Soviet of Workers‘ and Soldiers’ Deputies was established in the early days of the February Revolution and claimed supreme power not only in Petrograd, but in the whole of Russia.
The Tsar abdicated to the least of the evils - the State Duma. but they had no real power in the streets, so everything ended with the October Revolution.